Sony’s Appeal Denied; Fate of Dualshock Controller Uncertain (Pulled – Plagiarism)

Just to bring you up to speed: Immersion, a company specializing in haptic technology, in 2003 sued both Sony and Microsoft for patent infringement, claiming both companies used Immersion’s intellectual property (IP) in their console’s controllers. Microsoft settled out of court (buying a share of Immersion in the process), but Sony fought on. Sony lost, and the judge ruled that Sony must suspend the sale of “Playstation consoles, Dualshock controllers,” and a few dozen games, including Vice City, Final Fantasy X, and Metal Gear Solid 2. Sony filed for appeal, and has been allowed to sell all aforementioned products while the decision is under appeal.

While I am in no way a Sony fan, I have to side with them on this one. This is an excellent example of how ridiculous “intellectual property” law has become. Seriously, Immersion is trying to claim that they (and only they) have the rights to technology involving a non-symmetric mass rotating? Have any judges ever taken a single physics course? It’s based on concepts from Newtonian physics that are centuries old. Anyway, Sony is in a big mess right now. Forced through restructuring, problems with Blu-ray, problems with Cell, problems with release dates, problems with root kits, problems with rising consumer anger (mostly related to root kits), problems dealing with Korean MMORPG developers, problems with the cost of the PS3 (they have even gone on record saying the PS3 will be more of a family purchase and that they expect people to “work” for it), finally they are also currently having PR problems. Sony really needs to get it’s act together.

The Wall Street Journal this morning reports that a federal judge rejected Sony’s appeal and upheld the earlier decision (which also includes a $90.7 million payment by Sony to Immersion). Sony argued that Craig Thorner, a former paid consultant to Immersion, submitted testimony on Sony’s behalf. However, US District Judge Claudia Wilken noted that Thorner was an “unreliable” witness, citing “strong evidence” that suggest Thorner’s testimony was directly affected by the $150,000 Sony had paid him as “advance royalty” to license Thorner’s patents in the future.

“It seems very ridiculous that Sony would have to halt production on its flagship console, as well as most of the company’s best-selling titles, but that may very well be the case here. Could this be a reason for Sony’s (conceptual) “boomerang” PS3 controller? If the PlayStation 3 cannot utilize its force feedback technology from the past, how is this going to affect backwards compatibility? Chalk this up as another issue for Sony, alongside Cell processor issues, Blu-ray issues, delay rumors, and more than a few ad campaigns that have backfired.”

(Update: Apparently, Microsoft’s settlement was for $26 million which included a large peice of the company.)
Just to bring you up to speed: Immersion, a company specializing in haptic technology, in 2003 sued both Sony and Microsoft for patent infringement, claiming both companies used Immersion’s intellectual property (IP) in their console’s controllers. Microsoft settled out of court (buying a share of Immersion in the process), but Sony fought on. Sony lost, and the judge ruled that Sony must suspend the sale of “Playstation consoles, Dualshock controllers,” and a few dozen games, including Vice City, Final Fantasy X, and Metal Gear Solid 2. Sony filed for appeal, and has been allowed to sell all aforementioned products while the decision is under appeal.

While I am in no way a Sony fan, I have to side with them on this one. This is an excellent example of how ridiculous “intellectual property” law has become. Seriously, Immersion is trying to claim that they (and only they) have the rights to technology involving a non-symmetric mass rotating? Have any judges ever taken a single physics course? It’s based on concepts from Newtonian physics that are centuries old. Anyway, Sony is in a big mess right now. Forced through restructuring, problems with Blu-ray, problems with Cell, problems with release dates, problems with root kits, problems with rising consumer anger (mostly related to root kits), problems dealing with Korean MMORPG developers, problems with the cost of the PS3 (they have even gone on record saying the PS3 will be more of a family purchase and that they expect people to “work” for it), finally they are also currently having PR problems. Sony really needs to get it’s act together.

The Wall Street Journal this morning reports that a federal judge rejected Sony’s appeal and upheld the earlier decision (which also includes a $90.7 million payment by Sony to Immersion). Sony argued that Craig Thorner, a former paid consultant to Immersion, submitted testimony on Sony’s behalf. However, US District Judge Claudia Wilken noted that Thorner was an “unreliable” witness, citing “strong evidence” that suggest Thorner’s testimony was directly affected by the $150,000 Sony had paid him as “advance royalty” to license Thorner’s patents in the future.

“It seems very ridiculous that Sony would have to halt production on its flagship console, as well as most of the company’s best-selling titles, but that may very well be the case here. Could this be a reason for Sony’s (conceptual) “boomerang” PS3 controller? If the PlayStation 3 cannot utilize its force feedback technology from the past, how is this going to affect backwards compatibility? Chalk this up as another issue for Sony, alongside Cell processor issues, Blu-ray issues, delay rumors, and more than a few ad campaigns that have backfired.”

(Update: Apparently, Microsoft’s settlement was for $26 million which included a large peice of the company.)